| Location: | California |
|---|---|
| Posted: | Oct 6, 2026 |
| Due: | Nov 6, 2026 |
| Agency: | City of Coalinga |
| Type of Government: | State & Local |
| Category: |
|
| Publication URL: | To access bid details, please log in. |
| Bid Title: |
Comprehensive Fee Study and Cost Allocation
|
| Category: | RFP/RFQ's Solicitations |
| Status: | Open |
|
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
CITY OF COALINGA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
COMPREHENSIVE USER FEE STUDY AND COST ALLOCATION ANALYSIS
City of Coalinga
155 W. Durian Avenue
Coalinga, Ca 93210
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. PROJECT OVERVIEW
2. PROJECT SCOPE OF WORK
3. CITY BACKGROUND AND CURRENT STATUS
4. PROPOSAL REQUIREMENTS
5. EVALUATION AND SELECTION
6. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
APPENDIX A - CURRENT MASTER FEE SCHEDULE / FEE INVENTORY
APPENDIX B - COST PROPOSAL FORM
APPENDIX C - NON-COLLUSION / AUTHORIZED SIGNATURE
APPENDIX D - CITY PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
1. PROJECT OVERVIEW
1.1 Project Purpose
The City of Coalinga (City) is requesting proposals from qualified consulting firms to conduct a comprehensive
citywide User Fee Study. The City last completed a comprehensive fee study in 2015. The purpose of this
engagement is to update the City's fee structure to reflect the current reasonable cost of providing fee-supported
services; identify fees that are obsolete, duplicative, unclear, unsupported, under-recovering, or no longer aligned
with current service delivery; and establish a transparent, legally defensible, and sustainable framework for future
fee updates.
The City has already completed a separate cost allocation plan. Accordingly, preparation of a new citywide cost
allocation plan is not included in this RFP. The selected consultant shall use the City-provided cost allocation plan
and other approved overhead/indirect cost information as inputs to the fee study, validate their application to fee-
supported activities, and identify any concerns that materially affect fee calculations without recreating the cost
allocation plan.
The City's recent cost allocation review and approval was limited to positions that impact the Enterprise funds.
Positions outside that review, including Fire, Police, and other applicable positions, were not included. In addition
to the Comprehensive User Fee Study and the validation of the existing City-provided cost allocation information
described above, this RFP therefore includes a supplemental cost allocation analysis for those remaining
positions. This supplemental analysis is intended to complete the position-level allocation framework while
preserving the portions of the current cost allocation information that have already been reviewed and approved.
The study should support informed policy decisions regarding full cost recovery, appropriate public subsidies,
customer impacts, administrative efficiency, and implementation timing. Recommendations shall be consistent
with applicable federal, State of California, and local laws and regulations, including, as applicable, Article XIII C
and Article XIII D of the California Constitution (Propositions 26 and 218), Government Code sections 66014,
66016, 66018, 66019, and other laws governing municipal fees and charges.
1.2 Project Objectives
Review all City-adopted user fees and charges within the approved scope and determine the reasonable cost
of providing each fee-supported service.
Identify current cost recovery percentages, General Fund or other subsidies, and opportunities for appropriate
cost recovery improvements.
Identify services for which a fee may be appropriate but is not currently charged, as well as fees that should
be consolidated, restructured, clarified, or eliminated.
Ensure that recommended fees are supported by a clear, documented methodology and do not exceed the
reasonable cost of providing the associated service, except where otherwise lawfully authorized.
Provide policy options where immediate full cost recovery may be impractical, including phased
implementation or Council-directed subsidy levels.
Simplify and modernize the Master Fee Schedule to improve transparency, usability, and administration by
City staff and the public.
Provide fully editable, non-proprietary tools and documentation that City staff can maintain and update without
required consultant software or ongoing consultant dependency.
Establish a repeatable annual update methodology and a recommended schedule for future comprehensive
fee reviews.
Complete a supplemental, documented cost allocation analysis for Fire, Police, and other applicable positions
not included in the City's recently approved enterprise-related position allocation review, while preserving the
approved allocations and integrating the results into a coherent City allocation framework.
1.3 Scope Exclusions
Unless expressly added by written amendment, the following are outside the scope of this RFP:
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
| Contact | Information | ||||
| Name/Title | Mai Vang, Financial Services Director | ||||
| mvang@coalinga.com | |||||
| Telephone | (559) 935-1533 ext. 129 |
| Deadlines | Tentative Date | ||||
| RFP Issued | October 5, 2026 | ||||
| Deadline for Questions | October 16, 2026 | ||||
| City Responses / Addendum | October 30, 2026 | ||||
| Proposal Due | November 6, 2026 | ||||
| Interviews, if needed | Week of November 16th | ||||
| Notice of Intent to Award | Week of November 16th | ||||
| Protest Deadline | Five (5) business days following Notice of Intent to Award | ||||
| City Council Award | December 17, 2026 | ||||
| Project Kickoff | Week of January 11, 2027 | ||||
| Target Final Study / Adoption* | TBD |
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
Development Impact Fee nexus studies under the Mitigation Fee Act or AB 1600, except to identify such
fees as outside the user-fee study and avoid duplication.
Utility rate studies for water, wastewater/sewer, natural gas, or solid waste service rates. The study may
include miscellaneous utility service fees or administrative charges contained in the City's Master Fee
Schedule when legally appropriate, but shall not establish commodity or utility rates.
Taxes, assessments, fines, penalties, or charges whose amount is established by statute or another
agency, except for identification, classification, and administrative recommendations where useful.
1.4 RFP Coordinator
All communications concerning this RFP shall be directed in writing to the City's designated RFP Coordinator. The
Coordinator shall be the sole point of contact during the solicitation process.
Contact Information
Name/Title Mai Vang, Financial Services Director
Email mvang@coalinga.com
Telephone (559) 935-1533 ext. 129
1.5 RFP Schedule
The following schedule is tentative. The City reserves the right to modify the schedule by written notice or
addendum.
Deadlines Tentative Date
RFP Issued October 5, 2026
Deadline for Questions October 16, 2026
City Responses / Addendum October 30, 2026
Proposal Due November 6, 2026
Interviews, if needed Week of November 16th
Notice of Intent to Award Week of November 16th
Five (5) business days following Notice of Intent to
Protest Deadline
Award
City Council Award December 17, 2026
Project Kickoff Week of January 11, 2027
Target Final Study / Adoption* TBD
*The Target Date will be determined at the Project Kickoff meeting with the selected consulting firm.
2. PROJECT SCOPE OF WORK
The tasks below establish the minimum scope. Proposers are encouraged to recommend additional or alternative
methods that improve accuracy, legal defensibility, efficiency, transparency, or usability, provided the proposal
clearly identifies any deviation and associated cost.
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
2.1 Task 1 - Project Initiation and Data Validation
Conduct a kickoff meeting with Finance and participating departments to confirm scope, deliverables, roles,
schedule, and data requirements.
Prepare a detailed project work plan, data request list, responsibility matrix, and schedule with key decision
points and review periods.
Review the City's existing Master Fee Schedule, 2015 fee study and model, current policies and procedures,
relevant resolutions/ordinances, current budget and actual expenditure data, salary and benefit information,
staffing allocations, service statistics, and the City-provided cost allocation plan.
Conduct structured interviews or workshops with departments to document current workflows, service levels,
staffing effort, technology changes, online/self-service processes, outsourced services, and operational
changes since the prior study.
Identify data limitations and recommend reasonable, transparent assumptions where reliable historical data or
time records are unavailable.
Review, audit, and validate the current City-Provided Cost Allocation Plan (CAP) for compliance with California
Proposition 26 and applicable legal requirements before incorporating and applying CAP allocations to the
updated fee model.
2.2 Task 2 - Fee Inventory and Legal/Policy Classification
Develop a complete inventory of fees and charges within scope by department, service, legal authority,
current amount, calculation basis, and adopting authority.
Identify fees that are obsolete, duplicative, inconsistently applied, not formally adopted, no longer tied to a
current service, or missing from the Master Fee Schedule.
Identify services currently provided without an associated fee for which a user fee may be legally and
operationally appropriate.
Classify fees by applicable legal framework and flag items requiring special legal analysis, notice, hearing,
protest, or adoption procedures. The consultant shall coordinate with City staff and City Attorney as needed;
the consultant is not expected to provide legal representation.
Review the City's existing "Public Records Search" fee for compliance with the California Public Records Act.
The consultant shall remove from the current Master Fee Schedule all authorization to charge for staff or City
Attorney time spent searching for, reviewing, or redacting standard public records. This fee shall not be
calculated on a full cost-recovery basis and shall be limited to legally permissible direct duplication costs.
Costs for specialized electronic data extraction, compilation, programming, or computer services may be
included only to the extent expressly authorized by applicable law and shall be separately identified and
evaluated in coordination with the City Attorney.
Review and classify the quarterly business license charges imposed on professions and businesses, including
attorneys, physicians, and contractors, to determine whether each charge constitutes a tax, regulatory fee, or
other charge under applicable law. The consultant shall not apply a user-fee cost-recovery methodology or
recommend an increase to a charge classified as a tax. Any tax classification, voter-approval requirement, or
proposed change shall be separately identified and evaluated in coordination with the City Attorney before
inclusion in the recommended Master Fee Schedule.
Review the current Master Fee Schedule to identify and classify all fees, fines, penalties, and charges subject
to statutory caps, prescribed amounts, required adjustments, or other limitations that supersede or restrict a
local cost-recovery calculation. This review shall include, but is not limited to, municipal and fire-code citations,
utility reconnection charges, and residential and commercial solar permitting and plan-review fees. The
consultant shall separately identify the applicable statutory authority and limitation for each charge and shall
ensure that no cost-recovery calculation, CPI adjustment, or recommended amount exceeds or conflicts with
applicable law. Charges excluded from the user-fee analysis shall nevertheless be identified and correctly
classified in the recommended Master Fee Schedule in coordination with the City Attorney.
Separately identify charges outside the scope of this study, such as Development Impact Fees, utility
commodity rates, taxes, assessments, fines, and penalties, to avoid improper treatment as user fees.
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
2.3 Task 3 - Cost of Service and Cost Recovery Analysis
Determine the reasonable full cost of providing each fee-supported service using direct labor, benefits,
operating costs, contractual costs, applicable indirect/overhead allocations from the City-provided cost
allocation plan, and other supportable costs.
Document workload assumptions, service steps, productive hours, staff classifications, time estimates,
allocation bases, unit measures, and formulas used to calculate each fee.
Where appropriate, perform or facilitate representative time/workload studies or process mapping to validate
staff effort rather than relying solely on unsupported estimates.
Calculate current cost recovery percentages, full cost recovery fee levels, and subsidy amounts by fee/service.
Analyze a practical period of historical activity and revenue data, preferably two to three fiscal years where
reliable data is available, to identify volume trends, service-demand changes, revenue impacts, and unusual
or nonrecurring activity.
Identify instances of potential over-recovery as well as under-recovery, and recommend corrective action
consistent with applicable law.
Assess the treatment of deposits, pass-through costs, consultant deposits, actual-cost billing,
reinspection/review charges, credit-card or payment processing costs, technology-related service costs, and
other variable-cost items where applicable.
2.4 Task 4 - Fee Recommendations and Policy Options
Recommend a full cost recovery fee for each service, together with any policy-based fee level or subsidy
alternative that the consultant believes is appropriate for City consideration.
For significant increases, provide phased implementation options, where appropriate, and quantify the annual
revenue and subsidy implications of each option.
Recommend new fees, modified fees, consolidated fees, tiered fees, flat versus actual-cost billing methods,
minimum charges, deposits, or other structures that better reflect current service delivery and administrative
practices.
Identify fees that should be eliminated or replaced because they are obsolete, legally problematic, duplicative,
administratively inefficient, or no longer representative of the service provided.
Recommend an annual adjustment methodology, such as CPI or another appropriate index, but distinguish
between automatic inflationary adjustments and circumstances that should trigger a new cost-of-service
review.
Recommend a comprehensive fee-study review cycle and procedures for interim fee changes, including
documentation standards and internal responsibility for annual maintenance.
2.5 Task 5 - Peer Agency and Market Comparison
The consultant shall perform a targeted comparison with a reasonable group of comparable California public
agencies selected in consultation with the City. Comparisons are informational and shall not replace the City's
own cost-of-service basis for fee recommendations.
Consider population, service mix, geographic proximity, organizational structure, development activity, and
other relevant characteristics when recommending comparison agencies.
Compare selected high-impact or commonly used fees, fee structures, and cost recovery practices rather than
relying solely on a broad price comparison.
For facility rentals, recreation-type charges, or other services where market conditions may be a relevant
policy consideration, identify market comparisons separately from the legally supportable cost-of-service
calculation.
2.6 Task 6 - Modernization of the Master Fee Schedule
Prepare a consolidated, user-friendly Master Fee Schedule organized consistently by department and service
category.
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
Use plain-language fee descriptions and identify calculation units, deposits, hourly rates, pass-through
charges, actual-cost provisions, or other conditions clearly.
Recommend a numbering or coding structure that supports future maintenance and cross-reference to the
underlying fee model.
Where practical, structure the schedule and model to support publication to the City website and future
integration or reference within permitting, licensing, cashiering, ERP, or other digital systems.
Identify fees that are suitable for online/self-service transactions and any administrative efficiencies that may
affect the cost basis of those services.
2.7 Task 7 - Draft Study, Review, and Implementation Support
Prepare an administrative draft for staff review, incorporating department comments and documenting
unresolved policy decisions.
Prepare a management summary highlighting material fee changes, subsidy decisions, revenue impacts,
legal/policy considerations, and implementation choices.
Present findings to City management and conduct at least one working session with City staff.
Prepare presentation materials and participate in City Council meetings/workshops as needed, including the
final fee adoption hearing, unless otherwise proposed.
Provide a draft resolution and/or fee schedule exhibit suitable for City Attorney review and Council adoption.
Provide reasonable post-adoption implementation support up to two (2) years to address model questions,
corrections, or implementation issues attributable to the study.
2.8 Task 8 - Supplemental Cost Allocation Analysis for Positions Not
Included in the Approved Review
The City recently reviewed and approved cost allocations for positions that impact the Enterprise funds. Those
approved allocations are part of the City-provided cost allocation information and shall remain in place, subject
to the validation requirements elsewhere in this RFP.
Perform a supplemental cost allocation analysis for City positions that were not included in that approved
review, including Fire, Police, and other applicable positions or classifications identified by the City. The
purpose of this task is to establish and document reasonable, supportable allocations for the remaining
positions without recreating the portions of the cost allocation plan already reviewed and approved.
Review organizational responsibilities, position duties, budgeted staffing, payroll and benefit costs,
departmental and program relationships, available workload or activity data, and other relevant records
necessary to determine which funds, departments, programs, services, or activities benefit from each position
within the supplemental analysis.
Develop and document an appropriate allocation methodology and allocation basis for each position or group
of similarly situated positions. Allocation bases may include direct assignment, time or workload measures,
service calls, staffing, transactions, program activity, or another reasonable and consistently applied basis
supported by the nature of the services provided.
Where reliable time or workload records are unavailable, conduct interviews, facilitate reasonable time-
estimate exercises, or use other documented methods to develop supportable allocation percentages and
clearly identify assumptions and limitations.
Identify positions or portions of positions that should remain directly assigned to the General Fund or another
fund because a reasonable benefit or nexus to another fund, program, enterprise activity, or fee-supported
service cannot be demonstrated.
Ensure that the supplemental position allocations are consistent with applicable cost-allocation principles, the
City's fund structure and operations, and Proposition 26 considerations, and that costs are not shifted to
enterprise funds or fee-supported activities without a documented and supportable basis.
Integrate the supplemental position allocation analysis with the existing City-provided cost allocation
information so the City has a coherent, documented allocation framework for use in the User Fee Study and
for future budgeting and cost allocation updates. Any recommended change affecting an allocation that was
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
previously reviewed and approved shall be separately identified and shall not be incorporated without City
approval.
2.9 Required Deliverables
Project work plan, schedule, and data request list.
Fee inventory and legal/policy classification matrix.
Documented cost-of-service methodology and assumption log.
Cost recovery matrix showing current fee, calculated full cost, recommended fee, cost recovery percentage,
subsidy amount/percentage, percentage change, and projected revenue impact.
Historical fee activity and revenue analysis, where data is reliable and available.
Peer agency comparison report for selected fees.
Draft and final Comprehensive User Fee Study.
Recommended Master Fee Schedule in editable and publication-ready formats.
Fee implementation plan, including phased options where applicable.
Draft fee adoption resolution/exhibits for City Attorney review.
Fully editable fee model and supporting schedules.
Written annual update procedures / methodology manual.
Staff training session and training materials.
Council presentation materials.
Written assessment documenting the consultant's validation of the City-provided cost allocation plan, identified
deficiencies, recommended corrections, and the basis for determining that the allocations used in the fee
model comply with Proposition 26 and other applicable requirements.
Supplemental position cost allocation matrix identifying each position/classification analyzed, benefiting
fund(s), department(s), program(s) or activity(ies), allocation basis, recommended allocation percentages,
supporting assumptions, and source data.
Written methodology memorandum for the supplemental position cost allocation analysis, including
documentation of interviews or workload measures, treatment of positions not reasonably allocable outside
their direct fund, and any recommended changes requiring City approval.
Fully editable cost allocation schedules/model for the supplemental position analysis that can be updated by
City staff and reconciled to the City-provided cost allocation information.
2.10 Fee Model and Technology Requirements
The final model is a City work product and shall be transparent, auditable, and maintainable by City staff. At a
minimum:
The primary fee model shall be delivered in a commonly available, editable format such as Microsoft Excel,
unless the City approves an alternative.
All formulas, assumptions, lookup tables, allocation inputs, calculation logic, and supporting schedules shall
be visible and documented.
The model shall not require proprietary software, ongoing license fees, consultant-hosted access, password
protection, locked formulas, hidden worksheets, or consultant-owned calculation engines to perform routine
annual updates.
The model shall allow City staff to update salary/benefit costs, overhead inputs, service times, activity
volumes, and policy recovery percentages and to add, revise, or retire fees.
Where useful, the consultant should include scenario tools for full cost recovery, phased implementation, and
Council-directed subsidy options.
Electronic deliverables shall meet reasonable accessibility and records-retention needs and shall be provided
in native editable formats in addition to PDF.
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
2.11 Staff Training
The consultant shall provide practical training for Finance and designated department staff on the final fee model,
annual update process, documentation requirements, and procedures for adding or revising fees. Training should
be designed so the City can maintain the study without recurring consultant dependence.
3. CITY BACKGROUND AND CURRENT STATUS
3.1 City Background
The City of Coalinga is a California general law city operating under a Council-Manager form of government. The
City provides a range of municipal services that include public safety, community development, public works,
administrative services, and enterprise utility operations. Proposers should review the City's current organizational
structure, adopted budget, Municipal Code, and Master Fee Schedule as part of the engagement.
3.2 Current Fee Environment
The City completed its last comprehensive fee study in 2015. Since that time, service delivery methods, staffing,
labor and benefit costs, technology, permitting and payment processes, contractual services, legal requirements,
and community needs have changed. The City seeks a comprehensive update rather than a simple inflationary
adjustment of the prior fee schedule.
The City has separately completed a cost allocation plan that will be furnished to the selected consultant. The
selected consultant is expected to use that plan as the approved basis for applicable indirect and overhead costs,
subject to validation of how those costs are applied to individual fee-supported services.
The most recent City review and approval of position cost allocations addressed only positions impacting the
enterprise funds. Fire, Police, and other applicable positions were not included in that review. The selected
consultant shall perform the supplemental position cost allocation analysis described in Task 8 for those remaining
positions and integrate the results with the existing City-provided cost allocation information. The existing
approved enterprise-related allocations shall remain intact unless the consultant identifies a material concern
through the validation work required by this RFP, in which case the concern and any recommended change shall
be separately documented for City consideration.
4. PROPOSAL REQUIREMENTS
The City encourages concise proposals that provide a clear and complete response. Proposals shall be organized
in the order below.
4.1 Cover Letter
Identify the firm, primary contact, address, telephone number, and email. The letter shall be signed by a person
authorized to bind the firm and shall acknowledge all addenda.
4.2 Executive Summary
Provide a concise statement of the firm's understanding of the project, key qualifications, proposed approach, and
any distinguishing features of the proposal.
4.3 Firm Qualifications and Relevant Experience
Describe the firm's experience conducting comprehensive municipal user fee studies for California public
agencies. Identify at least three comparable projects completed within the last five years, preferably for agencies
of similar size or service complexity.
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis
CITY OF COALINGA | REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
4.4 Project Team
Identify the Project Manager and key personnel, roles, availability, relevant experience, and resumes. Identify all
subcontractors and their responsibilities. The City expects key personnel proposed to remain assigned for the
duration of the project unless the City approves a substitution.
4.5 Project Approach and Methodology
Describe the proposed methodology for fee inventory, departmental interviews, time/workload validation, cost-of-
service calculations, audit, validation, and use of the City's existing cost allocation plan, cost recovery analysis,
peer comparisons, policy options, model development, implementation, and staff training. Clearly identify
assumptions and any proposed deviations from the RFP.
The proposal shall also describe the firm's methodology for the supplemental position cost allocation analysis,
including how it will evaluate Fire, Police, and other positions not included in the approved enterprise-related
allocation review; select and document allocation bases; validate time/workload assumptions; distinguish direct
assignments from shared costs; and integrate the supplemental results with the existing City-provided cost
allocation information without unnecessarily recreating previously approved work.
4.6 Work Plan and Schedule
Provide a detailed schedule by task, milestone, deliverable, City review period, and required meeting. Identify the
information and expect staff participation from the City and any critical path items.
4.7 Deliverable Samples
Provide representative examples or screen captures of a municipal fee study report, cost recovery matrix, Master
Fee Schedule, and editable fee model previously prepared by the proposed team. Samples may be redacted as
necessary.
4.8 References
Provide at least three public-agency references for similar work completed by the proposed team within the last
five years, including agency, project, contact name/title, phone, email, completion date, and contract amount if
available.
4.9 Exceptions and Conflicts
Identify any exceptions to the RFP or City agreement, actual or potential conflicts of interest, and any material
litigation or claims related to similar professional services during the past five years.
4.10 Cost Proposal
Provide a separate detailed, not-to-exceed cost proposal by task and deliverable. Identify staff classifications,
hourly billing rates, estimated hours, reimbursable expenses, optional services, and any rate increases that could
occur during the proposed project period. The total not-to-exceed amount shall include all travel, meetings,
printing, administrative, and other costs unless clearly identified otherwise.
4.11 Proposal Validity
The proposal shall remain valid for at least ninety (120) days after the proposal due date.
Comprehensive User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Analysis

With GovernmentContracts, you can:
Follow UPDATE Request for Bids for Food Trucks at Rodeo Beach within Golden
INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF THE
Bid Due: 12/31/2026
GFO-26-302 - Food Production Investment Program 2026 Solicitation Type Grant Funding Opportunity Solicitation
California Energy Commission
Bid Due: 12/17/2026
Opportunity ID 224081 Organization City of Los Angeles Department Transportation Stage Open Contact
City of Los Angeles
Bid Due: 12/10/2026
Project ID: Title: 2026 Sewer Rehabilitation Project Addenda: 0 Release Date: 9/17/2026 Due
City of American Canyon
Bid Due: 1/12/2027