City of Midland Zoning Ordinance – Administrative Regulations Update
RFP # 4695
RFP # 4695
□ 1.0 Public Notice-Invitation for Zoning Ordinance – Administrative Regulations Update
This Request for Proposal (RFP) is issued by:
City of Midland (hereinafter “City”), 333 West Ellsworth Street, Midland, MI 48640.
□ 2.0 Background
The City seeks professional services to modernize Articles 4.00 (Nonconformities), 24.00 (Planned Unit Development), 27.00
(Site Plan Review), 28.00 (Conditional Land Use), 29.00 (Variances), 30.00 (Amendments), and 31.00 (Administrative
Organization) of the City’s zoning ordinance.
The City’s zoning ordinance was adopted in 2004, and the City’s master plan was adopted in 2024. The master plan includes
several goals and objectives which can be achieved in whole or in part through an update to the zoning ordinance. In
response, the City Planning Commission has initiated a phased modernization of the zoning ordinance. To date, articles of the
zoning ordinance establishing definitions, zoning districts, use standards, overlay standards, and dimensional standards have
been updated. Updates to articles regulating parking and loading, signs, walls and fences, and landscaping and screening are
currently underway.
Professional services are desired to support the modernization of the administrative articles of the zoning ordinance. The City
is seeking a modern, implementable update that is aligned with current legal precedents and best practices; produces quality
development and redevelopment; provides clarity and transparency to developers, property owners, and the public; ensures
equal protection and fairness; and meets the City’s land use planning objectives. The revised ordinance should also be clearly
organized, internally consistent, and written in plain, accessible language so that all users can readily understand applicable
standards and permitting requirements. A primary goal of this project is to identify opportunities to reduce unnecessary
regulatory barriers, processing time, uncertainty, and cost associated with development while maintaining appropriate
standards for development quality, development review, application processing, and implementation of the City’s master
plan.
Specific desired improvements include each of the following:
• Updating thresholds for administrative review to reduce the number of projects subject to public hearing
and reduce time and cost associated with taking projects from concept to completion.
• Replacing subjective review criteria, when appropriate, with clear/objective standards and checklists to reduce risk
and attract investment.
• Providing staff with the authority to address minor ordinance deviations to prevent unnecessary delays.
• Providing clear and concise standards for unique development formats through the Planned Unit Development
process.
This project is funded through a Housing Readiness Incentive Grant provided by the Michigan State Housing Development
Authority (MSHDA).
The City’s zoning ordinance is available online at https://www.cityofmidlandmi.gov/zoning. The City’s master plan is
available online at https://www.midlandcitymodern.com/.
□ 3.0 Scope of Services
Articles 4.00 (Nonconformities), 24.00 (Planned Unit Development), 27.00 (Site Plan Review), 28.00 (Conditional Land
Use), 29.00 (Variances), 30.00 (Amendments), and 31.00 (Administrative Organization) primarily contain regulations
governing the review and approval procedures associated with various processes available under the City’s zoning ordinance.
The selected consultant will prepare updated Articles that align with contemporary best practices for zoning administration
and the land use goals and vision contained in the City’s adopted master plan. The consultant shall review the existing articles
for consistency with the Michigan Zoning Enabling Act, other applicable federal and state legal requirements/relevant legal
precedent and recommend updates to ensure the revised ordinance is defensible, clearly organized, and practical to
administer. The updated articles should simplify structure and reduce unnecessary complexity in tables and cross-references.
City of Midland Zoning Ordinance – Administrative Regulations Update
RFP # 4695
As part of this work, the consultant shall also review the City’s existing development review processes, application
requirements, and forms associated with these Articles and recommend updates to improve efficiency, clarity, and
consistency with the revised ordinance.
Deliverables
The selected consultant shall provide the following:
• The consultant will schedule a kick-off meeting with the Planning Department to review and confirm alignment with the
scope, schedule, and deliverables.
• The consultant will work with the Planning Department to schedule progress meetings as needed, provide monthly
progress reports, and submit monthly invoices that provide clear explanations of the charges included. The consultant is
expected to lead the meetings and complete meeting minutes. Monthly progress reports should include issues requiring
City direction; performed work; upcoming tasks or milestones; status of scope, schedule, and budget; and risk
assessment and proposed mitigation. Progress meetings may occur virtually.
• The consultant will collect and analyze best practices in the administration of zoning from no fewer than five (5)
municipalities, including no fewer than three (3) located in Michigan. Best-practice examples should reflect Midland’s
key contexts and include municipalities that have successfully modernized administrative standards in order to
streamline development and redevelopment while also providing clarity, predictability, and transparency to the public.
The consultant will provide the City with a report summarizing these findings. The consultant will utilize these findings
to develop the proposed ordinance. The consultant shall also provide a summary of key legal and regulatory
considerations relating to zoning administration (including the Michigan Zoning Enabling Act and any relevant case
precedent) and describe how those considerations are addressed in the proposed ordinance.
• The consultant will review the City’s existing development review processes, application requirements, and forms
associated with the articles included in this project and identify recommended changes to improve efficiency, clarity, and
consistency with the proposed ordinance updates.
• The consultant shall identify where graphics, diagrams, or measurement illustrations would improve clarity and
incorporate them into the articles, as necessary.
• The consultant will provide a draft ordinance for review at 60% completion. The 60% draft shall identify major policy
decisions, open issues requiring City direction, and any unresolved cross-references or definitions. The consultant shall
also provide a brief summary of key changes from existing standards. City staff will provide commentary that is tracked
in a comment log maintained by the consultant. Where multiple regulatory approaches are available, the consultant shall
identify options and briefly describe the trade-offs associated with each option. The consultant shall also identify, but not
be responsible for drafting amendments to, any related ordinance provisions outside of the project articles that may
require amendments for consistency.
• The consultant will provide a draft ordinance for review at 90% completion. The 90% draft shall include a concise
summary of major changes, rationale, and anticipated impacts. The consultant will present the draft ordinance to the City
Planning Commission at a regularly scheduled meeting to solicit their feedback. City staff will provide final commentary
to be included in the final ordinance. The consultant will document and respond to all City comments and incorporate
revisions as directed by the City.
• The consultant will provide a final ordinance for adoption, including both redline and clean versions, and a brief
summary highlighting major changes and key cross-references. The summary should identify any administrative
procedures, definitions, related sections of the zoning ordinance, forms, or other development review materials that
should be updated for consistency.
• The consultant will attend and present the ordinance at three in-person public meetings: (1) introduction of the 90%
ordinance draft to the Planning Commission, (2) the Planning Commission public hearing, and (3) the City Council
public hearing.
□ 4.0 General Information
The City provides equal opportunities without regard to race, color, national origin, sex, age, disabilities, or veteran status or
any other classification protected by federal constitutional statutory law in educational programs and activities. This includes,
but is not limited to, admissions, educational services, financial aid, employment and retention of consultants and contractors.
Accordingly, all proposers entering contracts with City shall, upon request, be required to show proof of such
nondiscrimination.
The City encourages participation from small, minority-owned, women-owned, veteran-owned and labor surplus area
businesses. Incorporation of these types of firms into the proposer’s team is encouraged.
City of Midland Zoning Ordinance – Administrative Regulations Update
RFP # 4695
Proposer, their consultants, sub-consultants, or other parties representing the proposer for this solicitation may not contact any
member of the City of Midland Selection Panel concerning this project from the date of advertisement until after the date of
award.
The City intends to award a single contract for the entire scope to the proposer achieving the highest overall point score total,
as defined in the Evaluation section herein. The City reserves the right to reject any and/or all of the proposals, award portions
of the proposed work, or award portions of the proposed work to more than one proposer.
□ 5.0 Proposal
The purpose of the proposal is to provide members of the City of Midland Selection Panel with specific information
regarding the qualifications of the proposer and the proposed fee to complete the required services.
The proposer’s submittal must include the following, in the order listed, with sections divided by labeled tabs. No other
information is to be included. Inclusion of extraneous materials may result in rejection of proposal.
COVER LETTER (maximum 1 page): Cover letter to be submitted on official business letterhead addressing:
• The intent of the proposer to submit a response to this RFP.
• Acknowledgment of any Addenda.
• Acknowledgment that proposal is valid for ninety (90) days from submittal due date.
• Acknowledgment that proposer has no conflicts of interest that would affect its ability to enter into a contract if
selected.
• The primary contact person.
• Affirmation that signer is authorized to submit the proposal on behalf of proposer.
STATEMENT OF UNDERSTANDING (maximum 2 pages): Provide a concise narrative demonstrating the
proposer’s understanding of the project, including the City’s objectives for modernization of the administrative provisions of
the Zoning Ordinance and key legal, procedural, and implementation considerations anticipated as part of the project.
QUALIFICATIONS & EXPERIENCE (maximum 3 pages, not including resumes): Proposer, and any sub-
consultants anticipated to participate, should include:
• Brief history and description of proposer, including current corporate structure.
• A summary of proposer’s qualifications, including ability to fulfill the specific requirements of the RFP.
• Narrative describing prior experience preparing or updating zoning ordinances for no fewer than three
municipalities, including at least two Michigan communities.
• Brief resumes for all members of the proposed project team, including proposer’s personnel and any sub-consultants
proposed (resumes not to exceed 2 pages per team member).
• Provide firm’s proof of insurance which meets Federal, State, County, and local regulations.
• Provide proof of insurance that the licensees, lessees, and vendors have an approved Certificate of Insurance.
APPROACH & METHODOLOGY (maximum 4 pages): Provide a detailed explanation of the proposer’s approach
and methodology, including resources, methods, systems, and technologies to accomplish the tasks, services, and deliverables
specified in the Scope of Services. The response should describe how the proposer intends to carry out the work, including
their approach to key issues and policy decisions, coordination with City staff, and development of the required deliverables.
A proposed work plan and schedule identifying major tasks, meetings, milestones, and deliverables should also be included.
REFERENCES (maximum 1 page): Include contact information of at least three references familiar with the professional
services performed by proposer on similar efforts.
COST PROPOSAL: Include completed Attachment II – Cost Proposal.
A single lump-sum fee is required on the Cost Proposal form. Proposer’s fee will be entered into the cost proposal
calculation, and the resulting point score comprises fifteen percent (15%) of total point score, as defined in the Evaluation
section herein.
City of Midland Zoning Ordinance – Administrative Regulations Update
RFP # 4695
No compensation other than the lump-sum fee for the full scope of the services will be available.
5.1 Deadline and Submittal
One (1) hardcopy original in a binder and one (1) electronic version consisting of single .pdf file exactly matching the
hardcopy version on USB drive shall be submitted to the City’s official point of contact not later than the date and time
advertised. Proposer is solely responsible for properly labeling, mailing and/or delivering of proposal, at proposer’s sole cost.
Proposals may be hand-delivered if preferable.
The outside of the proposal’s envelope/box (or outermost envelope/box if mailed by and delivered by United
States Mail, Express Mail, Priority Mail, UPS, Federal Express, and all other similar types of carrier delivery,)
must be labeled with proposer’s company name and RFP Number: Zoning Ordinance – Administrative
Regulations Update RFP # 4695.
5.2 Point of Contact for RFP
Official City of Midland Point of Contact, for submission of Proposals and any correspondence related to this RFP:
Christina Evans
Accounting Manager
City of Midland, Michigan
333 West Ellsworth Street
Midland, MI, 48640
(989) 837-3331
purchasing@midland-mi.org
Any inquiries or other correspondence regarding this RFP are to be transmitted via US Mail or email to the Official Point of
Contact. DO NOT CALL – the telephone number is provided for courier delivery purposes only.
5.3 Required Review and Waiver of Objections by Proposers
Proposers should carefully review this RFP and all attachments for defects, objections, or any other matter requiring
clarification or correction. Questions or comments must be received by City in writing no later than six (6) business days prior
to the RFP submission deadline, to allow issuance of any necessary addenda.
*Submittal of a proposal shall constitute acceptance of the terms, conditions, criteria, requirements, and evaluation process of
the RFP and resulting contract, and operates as a waiver of any objection.
5.4 Response Withdrawal
Proposers may withdraw a submitted proposal at any time up to the deadline for submittal. To withdraw a response, the
respondent must submit a written request, signed by the proposer’s authorized representative, to the City’s point of contact
before the submission deadline. After withdrawing a previously submitted proposal, the proposer may submit another
proposal at any time up to the submission deadline.
5.5 Response - Amendments and Errors
Proposers are liable for any errors or omissions contained in their proposals. No amendments, revisions, or alterations to
proposals may be made following submission.
5.6 Property of Response
Proposals submitted in response to this RFP become the property of City. Selection or rejection of a response does not affect
this right. All submitted information shall be held in confidence during the evaluation process.
5.7 Insurance Requirements
City of Midland Zoning Ordinance – Administrative Regulations Update
RFP # 4695
Proposer is required to possess the following minimum insurance coverages:
General Liability
$1,000,000 per occurrence, $2,000,000 aggregate
Automobile liability
$1,000,000
Workers’ Comp
$500,000
Umbrella
$2,000,000
5.8 Addenda
Prior to the deadline for submission of RFP, the City reserves the right to issue addenda to this RFP. Proposers are
responsible for ensuring receipt of all addenda and incorporating any changes into their proposal. Proposers shall
acknowledge receipt of all addenda by listing those received in the RFP. The City reserves the right to reject a proposal for
failure to acknowledge receipt of any addenda. Addenda will be posted at https://www.cityofmidlandmi.gov and
https://bidnetdirect.com.
□ 6.0 Evaluation Criteria and Selection Process
6.1 Evaluation and Selection
Proposals submitted in response to this RFP will be evaluated by a City of Midland Selection Panel for the purpose of selecting the
Consultant that provides the best value for the City, based on the following criteria:
Statement of Understanding (0 to 25 points possible)
Consultant will be evaluated based on their understanding of the scope of services requested.
Approach & Methodology (0 to 35 points possible)
Consultant will be evaluated based on their proposed methodologies, technologies and strategies for providing the services
requested in this RFP.
Qualifications & Experience (0 to 25 points possible)
Consultant will be evaluated based on their experience related to projects similar in scope and magnitude of services requested in
this RFP and their ability to deliver a quality product on time and on budget. Each resume should include breadth and depth of
experience related to city planning, zoning administration, and zoning ordinance modernization, citing specific projects with
references. References may be contacted.
Financial Proposal (0 to 15 points possible)
Consultant will be evaluated based on their lump sum bid provided on the Financial Proposal form, included herein. Consultant shall
include completed Financial Proposal form with their proposal. Proposer’s fee will be entered into the Cost Proposal calculation to
derive point score. Selection Panel reviewers will be provided with lowest total fee for purposes of calculating Cost Proposal Score.
The Cost Proposal calculation for this RFP:
Cost Proposal Score = (Lowest Total Fee from any responsible Proposer divided by Proposer’s Total Fee) multiplied by 15.
6.2 Selection Process
All responsible Proposals submitted for this project will be reviewed by the Selection Panel. The selection process shall be as
follows:
• Each Selection Panel member will independently evaluate each proposal submitted in accordance with the
aforementioned criteria.
• Each member will compile a total point score for each proposal. The highest possible score for each proposal is 100
points.
• Member scores shall be combined for each consultant to produce a cumulative score.
• At this point the Selection Panel may select the highest scoring firm/team and award the contract. The Selection
Panel may also choose to invite the highest-ranking firms to make Oral Presentations to the RFP Selection Panel at a
subsequent meeting.
o If oral presentations are deemed necessary by the Selection Panel, the Selection Panel shall convene to hear Oral
Presentations. Upon completion of the Presentations each member shall re-evaluate and complete their scoring
and member scores shall be combined for each presenting consultant to produce a cumulative score.
• The Selection Panel reserves the right to discuss consultants being considered after initial scoring and before award
This is the opportunity summary page. It provides an overview of this opportunity and a preview of the attached documentation.