City-Wide Total Compensation Study

Location: California
Posted: Oct 1, 2026
Due: Nov 2, 2026
Agency: City of Atwater
Type of Government: State & Local
Category:
  • B - Special Studies and Analyses - Not R&D
  • C - Architect and Engineering Services - Construction
Publication URL: To access bid details, please log in.
Title & Document Issued Submissions Due
City-Wide Total Compensation Study October 1st, 2026 4:00 P.M. PT
November 2nd, 2026

Attachment Preview

CITY OF ATWATER, CA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL (RFP)
FOR
CITY-WIDE TOTAL COMPENSATION STUDY
RFP RELEASE DATE: October 1, 2026
PROPOSALS MUST BE RECEIVED BY
4:00 P.M. on November 2, 2026

C A
ITY OF TWATER
CITY-WIDE TOTAL COMPENSATION STUDY
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL
Table of Contents
INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 3
BACKGROUND ................................................................................................................ 3
OBJECTIVE ...................................................................................................................... 3
PROJECT SCHEDULE .................................................................................................... 4
SCOPE OF SERVICES ..................................................................................................... 4
PROPOSAL FORMAT AND CONTENT ....................................................................... 5
CRITERIA FOR SELECTION ........................................................................................ 7
PROPOSAL REQUIREMENTS ...................................................................................... 8
General Requirements .................................................................................................... 8
Submission of Proposal ................................................................................................. 9
Format for Proposal ....................................................................................................... 9
GENERAL .......................................................................................................................... 9
City Requirements ......................................................................................................... 9
Attachment 1: Special Conditions .................................................................................. 11
Attachment 2: City of Atwater Professional Services Agreement ............................... 14
Page 2 of 30

INTRODUCTION
The City of Atwater (hereinafter referred to as the "City") is requesting proposals from
qualified firms to conduct a City-wide Total Compensation Study. The purpose of the study is
to assist the City in maintaining a competitive compensation program that supports the
recruitment and retention of a high-quality workforce and provides a sound basis for
compensation decisions. The selected consultant will be expected to conduct a
comprehensive review of the City's existing classifications, salary ranges, and employee
benefits; compare the City's compensation practices with those of appropriate comparable
public agencies; evaluate internal relationships and equity; and provide practical
recommendations for maintaining a competitive and sustainable total compensation
program.
All proposals must be received by the City, no later than 4:00 PM on November 2, 2026. Late
proposals will not be considered. The City desires to enter into an agreement for professional
services with a qualified consultant that can demonstrate substantial experience conducting
compensation and classification studies for public agencies, preferably California cities and
other comparable governmental organizations. In addition to technical expertise, the City
seeks a consultant that can communicate effectively with City management, employees, and
elected officials and provide clear, defensible recommendations.
The City reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, to waive any informality in the
proposal process, and to select the proposal that, in the City's judgment, provides the best
overall value. Cost alone shall not be the determinative factor.
The request for proposals does not oblige the City to award a contract or complete the project
and the City reserves the right to cancel the solicitation if deemed in its best interest. There is
no express or implied obligation for the City to reimburse respondents for any expenses
incurred in preparing proposals in response to this RFP, including any expenses incurred due
to participation in this RFP process; the City shall not reimburse respondents for any such
expenses.
The City reserves the right to retain all proposals submitted and to use any ideas in a proposal
regardless of whether a specific respondent is ultimately selected. Submission of a proposal
indicates acceptance by the consultant of the conditions contained in this RFP, unless clearly
and specifically otherwise noted in the proposal submitted and confirmed in the subsequent
contract between the City and the selected consultant.
BACKGROUND
The City of Atwater has a population of approximately 32,000. The City is located on State
Route 99 in Merced County, in California's Great San Joaquin Valley.
The City is a general-law City that operates under a Council-Manager form of government,
with a five-member City Council. The City Council appoints the City Manager and City Attorney.
Page 3 of 30

The City is a full-service city. The City is divided into departments that provide a full range of
municipal services, including police, fire, public works, community development, and
administration. Information regarding the City and its organization, such as governmental
structure, services provided, the current Operating and Capital Budgets, and Annual Financial
Reports are available on the City's website at https://www.atwater.org/departments/finance/.
The City's organization includes multiple departments and a variety of classifications
encompassing management, supervisory, professional, technical, administrative and other
municipal positions.
The City is seeking a comprehensive and objective review of its compensation structure to
ensure that compensation practices remain competitive within the relevant labor market
while maintaining appropriate internal relationships and equity.
PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES
The purpose of the Total Compensation Study is to provide the City with current, credible, and
actionable information regarding employee compensation and benefits and to support the
City's ability to recruit and retain qualified employees.
The objectives of the study include, but are not limited to:
1. Evaluate the competitiveness of the City's salary ranges in relation to an appropriate
market of comparable public agencies.
2. Review the City's classification structure and evaluate internal salary relationships and
equity among classifications.
3. Recommend appropriate salary ranges based on market data, classification
responsibilities, internal relationships, and other relevant factors.
4. Review the competitiveness of benefits, including retirement, health insurance, leave
benefits, deferred compensation, and other compensation components.
5. Identify opportunities to improve promotional opportunities and recognizable
compensation growth.
6. Provide recommendations concerning staff alignments, reporting relationships, and
organizational structure where supported by the study.
7. Provide City staff with practical tools and guidance to maintain the compensation
system between formal studies.
The selected consultant shall propose a detailed project schedule identifying anticipated
dates for the project kickoff, data collection, stakeholder engagement, classification review,
compensation and benefits analysis, draft findings, City review, final report, and presentation
to the City Council. The City anticipates that the study will be completed within approximately
four (4) months following City Council approval, subject to the availability of City and
Consultant staff and timely receipt of requested information.
Page 4 of 30

PROJECT SCHEDULE
Below is the tentative time schedule for this process; however, dates may be subject to change
and adjusted as necessary.
RFP Issued October 1, 2026
Questions due October 12, 2026
Responses to Questions Provided October 19, 2026
Proposal Submittal Deadline November 2, 2026
Screening / Ranking and
Oral Interviews (at City discretion) November 9-13, 2026
Contract awarded by City Council December 14, 2026
SCOPE OF SERVICES
The City of Atwater is seeking a qualified consultant to conduct a comprehensive City-wide Total
Compensation Study. The study shall include all existing City job classifications. The Consultant
shall evaluate salary, total compensation, internal equity, classification relationships, market
competitiveness, and the City's overall compensation structure, and shall provide practical
recommendations for implementation.
The scope of work includes, but is not limited to, the following:
A. Classification Review.
1. Review all existing City job classifications and classification specifications, including
represented and unrepresented classifications, as applicable.
2. Evaluate duties, responsibilities, complexity, organizational relationships, and other
factors relevant to internal equity and market comparisons.
3. Identify classifications or classification relationships that warrant further review.
B. Comparable Agencies and Labor Market.
1. Work with the City to identify comparable agencies. Document the rationale and
relevant characteristics of the comparator group, including geography, population,
organizational structure, services provided, workforce characteristics, and relevant
labor-market considerations.
2. Identify material limitations in available comparison data.
C. Salary Market Survey.
1. Conduct a salary survey for all existing City classifications.
2. Compare minimum, midpoint, maximum, steps where applicable, range width, and
other relevant salary information.
3. Identify classifications that are below, at, or above the market and explain the
methodology used to determine market positioning and recommended salary ranges.
Page 5 of 30

D. Salary Structure
1. Evaluate the City's overall salary structure, including range widths, grade spacing,
salary differentials, midpoint relationships, step progression, and relationships among
classifications.
2. Recommend changes needed to maintain an equitable, competitive, and sustainable
salary structure.
E. Total Compensation and Benefits.
1. Evaluate salary and total compensation, including employer retirement costs, health,
dental, vision, life, and disability coverage, retiree medical, vacation, sick leave,
holidays, administrative/management leave, deferred compensation, uniform
allowances, educational or certification incentives, bilingual pay, longevity, specialty
assignment pay, on-call/call-back compensation, overtime, and other material
premium pays, as applicable.
2. Quantify employer cost and/or benefit value to the extent reasonably available.
F. Internal Equity and Salary Compression.
1. Analyze relationships among classifications, including supervisor/subordinate,
entry/journey/senior, manager/director, department director, and other material
relationships.
2. Identify compression or inequity created by market conditions or prior compensation
adjustments and recommend corrective actions.
G. Employee and Stakeholder Engagement
1. In consultation with the City, conduct appropriate meetings or interviews with the
City Manager, Human Resources, and other stakeholders identified by the City.
2. If requested, conduct employee focus groups and/or an employee survey regarding
recruitment, retention, and organizational concerns.
H. Recruitment and Retention
1. Evaluate factors affecting the City's ability to recruit and retain qualified employees,
using available City information and market data. Identify classifications or
compensation components presenting significant recruitment or retention concerns.
I. Implementation and Fiscal Impact
1. Provide recommended salary and/or compensation adjustments by classification,
implementation priorities, estimated annual fiscal impact, and estimated salary-
related benefit costs to the extent reasonably determinable.
2. Address employees below a proposed range minimum, within the proposed range, or
above a proposed range maximum. Provide phased implementation options if
appropriate.
J. Deliverables
1. Provide a written report describing the methodology, comparator agencies, market
Page 6 of 30

data, benefits analysis, internal equity findings, salary structure analysis, conclusions,
and recommendations.
2. Provide an executive summary, detailed salary and total compensation tables for all
classifications, and implementation matrix, supporting electronic data/workbooks to
the extent permitted.
K. Presentations and Meetings
1. Meet with City staff throughout the project to discuss methodology, preliminary
findings, and recommendations, and present final findings and recommendations to
the City Council and/or other City representatives as requested.
L. Final Recommendations
1. Recommendations shall be based on market competitiveness, internal equity,
recruitment and retention, classification responsibilities, total compensation, fiscal
considerations, and the City's organizational needs. The Consultant shall clearly
identify the basis for each major recommendation.
PROPOSAL FORMAT AND CONTENT
The responder shall be responsible for preparing an effective, clear, and concise proposal. All
interested responders are required to submit their qualifications and capabilities to provide
Total Compensation services in accordance with the conditions and dates outlined in this RFP.
Each proposal should be organized to clearly address the following requirements, at a
minimum:
A. Qualifications and Experience
1. Provide a brief history of your business entity and project team. Identify legal form,
ownership, and senior officials of company. Identify the name and email of the main
contact, including phone number and e-mail address. Include the website address (if
applicable). If proposing a sub-consultant, describe the division of responsibilities
between participating parties, and offices (location) that would be the primary
participants.
2. Describe professional experience and number of employees (licensed professionals,
technical support) on the proposed project team in servicing government clients.
Include the number and types of government clients you are currently servicing. Be
very specific about relevant experience with California government clients in the
past five (5) years.
3. Provide a statement of your Firm's knowledge and adherence to California
Government Code, and other applicable laws and regulations.
4. Describe any failure or refusal to complete a contract, including details and dates.
5. List any disciplinary or investigative action, including audits, in the past five (5) years
conducted by any professional body or local, state, or federal branch of government
of your Firm.
6. List any all litigation, pending or final, to which you are a party that is related or
Page 7 of 30

similar to the services being solicited in the past five (5) years.
B. Staffing
Provide a list and resumes of individual(s) who will be working on this project, their relevant
experience, and indicate the functions that each will perform and anticipated hours of service
of each individual.
C. Work Schedule
Provide a detailed timeline identifying the tasks required and anticipated start and completion
dates for each task. Include the anticipated dates for data collections, analysis, draft findings,
review meetings, final report, and presentation(s).
D. Structure and Content of Work Product
Describe the manner in which the work product will be structured and presented upon
completion. Identify proposed reports, data tables, recommendations, electronic deliverables,
and computer/software compatibility.
E. Similar Projects
Provide a list of at least three (3) government clients, preferably California government clients,
that your firm or agency has provided Total Compensation Study data to over the last five (5)
years. If your firm or agency is unable to provide a listing of government clients, then provide
a listing of five (5) private sector clients that your firm or agency has provided Total
Compensation Study data to over the last five (5) years. The City reserves the right to contact
any of the organizations or individuals listed. The information provided shall include:
1. Organization's Name
2. Address
3. Reference contact person and title, telephone number and e-mail address.
4. Describe the nature of the services provided, initial date of the engagement, and
expiration date of the contract.
F. Fee Proposal
All proposers shall submit a proposal which delineates tasks, hours and costs for all staff
working on the project. Include any proposed cost savings or credits associated with existing
compensation survey data that the consultant can provide and share with the City rather than
independently gathering the same data. Proposals shall be valid for a minimum of 180 days
following submission.
CRITERIA FOR SELECTION
An evaluation committee will evaluate each respondent's relevant experience and expertise.
Proposals will be evaluated based on the information presented in the RFP.
A two-step analysis will be employed. First, staff will review all submittals to ensure that the
minimum requirements of the RFP are met.
Page 8 of 30

Criteria POINTS
Presentation, completeness, clarity, organization, and conformance to the RFP content and format requirements. 10
Qualifications and experience - Demonstrated experience conducting compensation and/or classification studies for public agencies, particularly California cities; demonstrated professional skills, qualifications, and credentials of staff assigned to the study; quality, clarity, completeness, and organization of the proposal; references and demonstrated success with comparable jurisdictions. 40
Understanding and approach - Demonstrated understanding of the challenges associated with compensation studies and communicating findings to employees, management, and elected officials; ability to perform the work within the proposed timeframe. 30
References - Client references as to past project performance 20
Total Points 100

Secondly, an evaluation committee will review proposals for the following:
Criteria POINTS
Presentation, completeness, clarity, organization, and conformance to 10
the RFP content and format requirements.
Qualifications and experience - Demonstrated experience conducting
compensation and/or classification studies for public agencies, 40
particularly California cities; demonstrated professional skills,
qualifications, and credentials of staff assigned to the study; quality,
clarity, completeness, and organization of the proposal; references
and demonstrated success with comparable jurisdictions.
Understanding and approach - Demonstrated understanding of the 30
challenges associated with compensation studies and communicating
findings to employees, management, and elected officials; ability to
perform the work within the proposed timeframe.
References - Client references as to past project performance 20
Total Points 100
The City reserves the right to interview any or all responding proposers and/or to award a
contract without conducting interviews.
A recommendation for a firm's selection will be made to the City Council based on the "best
value" evaluation of the proposals/qualifications, which will take into account the criteria
above. All interested parties are encouraged to submit proposals to the RFP. The award is
not based solely on the lowest cost proposal submitted. Total cost will be taken into
consideration but will not be the determining factor when selecting a firm, instead, the City
reserves the right to choose the best proposer overall according to the City's criteria. The City,
and its designated representatives, shall be the sole judge of its own best interest, the proposal,
the criteria, and the resulting negotiated agreement. The City's decisions will be final.
The above factors, along with other factors that the City may deem appropriate, will be used
to identify the proposal that represents the best value, which will be the basis for the contract
award. The decision of whether to award a contract and selection of a consultant will be in
the sole discretion of the City Council. The City reserves the right to not make an award, to
cancel the RFP in whole or in part, or to re-solicit the RFP, at the City's sole discretion.
PROPOSAL REQUIREMENTS
The City will not give verbal answers to clarifications regarding information in this RFP, or
verbal instructions prior to the submission deadline. All clarifications requests shall be
submitted in writing. A verbal statement in response to a clarification request by any person
shall be non-binding. The City is not liable for any increased costs resulting from a responder
Page 9 of 30

accepting verbal directions. Any explanation desired by a responder must be requested of the
City representative below in writing no later than October 16, 2026 at 4:00 PM.
Inquiries concerning the Request for Proposals and the subject of the Request for Proposals
must be made to:
City Clerks' Office
Attn: Gisela Peralta
City of Atwater
1160 Fifth Street
Atwater, CA 95301
209-357-6300
cityclerk@atwater.org
Submission of Proposal: Each proposer shall submit one (1) electronic copy of the SQQ in PDF
format via email (maximum file size 15 MB), labeled with the consultant's name. A separate
electronic file containing the proposed fee schedule shall also be submitted.
Format for Proposal
To facilitate the review of responses, all responses are required to adhere to the following
requirements regarding their proposal. The City strongly encourages respondents to ensure that
RFP submissions are succinct and clearly organized. If the proposal is not in this format or does
not include all the listed items, it may be deemed non-responsive.
1. Title Page showing the request for proposals subject; the firm's name; the name,
address and telephone number of the contact person; and the date of the proposal.
2. Table of Contents identifying the materials submitted by section and page number.
3. Detailed Proposal following the order set forth in the Proposal Content.
GENERAL
Addenda to this RFP, if issued, will be posted on the City of Atwater website at:
https://www.atwater.org/bids-rfps-rfqs/
The Consultant may recommend other tasks that it deems appropriate to achieve the objectives
set forth in this RFP.
The successful respondent shall be required to retain all working papers and relating supporting
documents, including records of professional time spent, for a period of five (5) years after
delivery of the required reports, unless notified in writing by the City of the need to extend the
retention period. The Consultant further agrees to allow City staff to review such documents
upon written request at any time during the retention period.
City Requirements
The firm must comply with all relevant City requirements, such as providing proof of insurance
Page 10 of 30

This is the opportunity summary page. It provides an overview of this opportunity and a preview of the attached documentation.
Daily notification on new contract opportunities

With GovernmentContracts, you can:

  • Find more opportunities and win more business
  • Receive daily alerts for all new bid opportunities
  • Get contract opportunities matched to your business
ONE WEEK FREE TRIAL

See also

Follow UPDATE Request for Bids for Food Trucks at Rodeo Beach within Golden

INTERIOR, DEPARTMENT OF THE

Bid Due: 12/31/2026

GFO-26-302 - Food Production Investment Program 2026 Solicitation Type Grant Funding Opportunity Solicitation

California Energy Commission

Bid Due: 12/17/2026

Opportunity ID 224081 Organization City of Los Angeles Department Transportation Stage Open Contact

City of Los Angeles

Bid Due: 12/10/2026

Project ID: Title: 2026 Sewer Rehabilitation Project Addenda: 0 Release Date: 9/17/2026 Due

City of American Canyon

Bid Due: 1/12/2027

* Disclaimer: Information regarding bids, requests for proposals (RFPs), or requests for qualifications (RFQs) is provided on this website only for convenience and does not constitute official public notice. Persons wishing to respond to or inquire about bids, RFPs, or RFQs should contact the appropriate government department.